Caldwell Savages Super Rothschild
Posted on February 26 2021
Vitola: 4.75x52 | Smoking Time: 65 min | Cigars Smoked: 3 | Body: Medium | MSRP: $12.30
Wrapper: Habano | Binder: Dominican | Filler: Dominican, Nicaraguan
Caldwell Cigars was founded in 2014 to "create special cigars using well-aged rare tobaccos." Robert Caldwell’s portfolio is vast, wild in name and blend, and consistently receives raving reviews.
Visual Inspection: Smooth but fragile light brown Habano wrapper with the slightest rosado tint. Pigtail cap, no soft spots. Foot aroma: barnyard, cinnamon, pie crust. Cold draw: herbal tea with honey, vanilla, and cedar.
First Third: Took the flame like a champ. Surprisingly nutty — toast, light roasted coffee, cinnamon, and vanilla. Burn line wavy at first but self-corrected. Well-constructed head held through some rough handling.
Second Third: Unbelievably smooth. Creamier now — half and half, butter crackers, almond, green tea, vanilla, and honey. Very welcoming with little to no bitterness or spice. Touched burn line once, then perfect.
Final Third: More full-bodied but not peppery — cinnamon candy, nutmeg, and a hint of sriracha. Same delectable base of vanilla, cream, almond, and toast, with a finish of lemon zest.
Final Thoughts: I’m becoming a huge Caldwell fan. Quality is consistent and flavors are complex. Savages is a great morning stick with coffee or a sweet treat. Box-worthy and frequently passed around at LCC as a treat.
-Sam
Frequently asked questions
What is the best pairing for the Caldwell Savages?
The reviewer recommends it as a morning stick with coffee or a sweet treat. The medium body and Habano wrapper’s balanced spice and earthiness complement breakfast pairings very well.
Who founded Caldwell Cigars?
Robert Caldwell founded Caldwell Cigars in 2014 with a focus on creating special cigars using well-aged, rare tobaccos. He’s built the brand on unique blends and partnerships with top Nicaraguan and Dominican factories.
How complex is the Caldwell Savages?
Very complex for the price. The reviewer highlights how flavors evolve throughout the 65-minute burn — the Habano wrapper contributes nuance that makes it worth smoking slowly.